Cloth vs disposable

Before Mason was born, Clayton and I decided that we didn't want to contribute to adding more plastic to our landfills.  I researched a few diaper services in the Lower Mainland and chose the best value for our money.

We are now into 3 months of using the cloth diapers and I thought I would share our experiences this far....

From birth, Mason goes through 80 diapers per week

Benefits of Cloth


  • Enviro friendly!

  • Package cost includes; pail, clean diapers, diaper sack

  • Cost effective? This is up for discussion.  The Diaper service provides a cost comparison to disposables but who knows if it's all that accurate


  • Disadvantages of Cloth

  • Need to be changed more often

  • Leakage from side

  • Leakage from back (mostly for boy babies)

  • Diaper cover smells like pee (cause it's covered in pee!)

  • Set # of diapers per week, if you run out you need to have disposables on hand

  • The diaper pail gets full fast (the bin I have barely holds all 80 diapers by the time of pick-up)

  • Need to carry around dirty diapers when on the road

  • Add bulk to baby body, clothes fit a bit more snug in length

  • May cause diaper rash because skin is exposed to wet longer (not in my case though)

  • The covers must be purchased or rented (I prefer Kushies brand from Sears. $8 per cover.  Buy 5!)


  • Benefits of Disposables

  • No leaks

  • No urine smell

  • Use and toss in the garbage

  • Can change baby less often


  • Disadvantages of Disposables

  • Bad bad bad for the environment (500 years to decompose)

  • Some of the scented diapers smell awful (very chemical-ly)

  • Can be costly

  • Go Back

    Comment